Skip to main content

Loan Calculator

If you’re buying a car in Australia, a secured car loan will often cost less than an unsecured personal loan. That’s because the vehicle acts as security for the loan, reducing the lender’s risk. In return, you may receive a lower interest rate.

However, a personal loan can be more suitable in certain situations, such as buying an older vehicle, purchasing from a private seller or wanting to avoid using your car as security.

The right choice depends on more than the advertised interest rate. Loan fees, repayment flexibility, loan terms and lender conditions can all affect the total cost.

In this guide, we’ll compare personal loans and car loans, explain their differences and look at which option may suit different car buyers.

What’s the Difference Between a Car Loan and a Personal Loan?

A car loan is finance specifically intended for purchasing a vehicle. Many car loans are secured, meaning the vehicle acts as collateral for the loan.

If you fail to meet your repayments, the lender may be able to repossess and sell the vehicle to recover the outstanding debt. Because the lender has an asset as security, secured car loans often have lower interest rates than unsecured personal loans.

A personal loan can be used for various purposes, including buying a new or used car. Most standard personal loans are unsecured, meaning you don’t offer your vehicle or another asset as security.

Without an asset to recover if you default, the lender takes on more risk. This can mean higher interest rates or stricter lending criteria.

It’s important to remember that not every car loan is secured. Some lenders offer unsecured car finance, so check the actual loan agreement rather than relying on the product name.

What Does It Mean to Use Your Car as Security?

When you take out a secured car loan, the lender registers its security interest over the vehicle. This can be recorded on the Personal Property Securities Register (PPSR). You generally cannot sell or transfer the vehicle without first dealing with the outstanding finance and the lender’s security interest.

Lenders may also have conditions relating to:

  • The vehicle’s age and condition
  • The vehicle’s purchase price and valuation
  • Whether the car is purchased from a dealer or private seller
  • Comprehensive insurance requirements

These conditions vary between lenders. An unsecured personal loan generally gives you more freedom over the vehicle because it isn’t being used as collateral.

Car Loan vs Personal Loan: Side-by-Side Comparison

The following table highlights some common differences between secured car loans and unsecured personal loans.

FeatureSecured car loanUnsecured personal loan
SecurityThe vehicle is used as securityNo asset is generally required
Interest rateOften lowerOften higher
Loan amountCan offer higher borrowing limitsLimits vary by lender and borrower
Rate typeUsually fixed, depending on lenderFixed or variable
Private purchases and older vehiclesSome lenders restrict private sales or set vehicle age and condition limitsGenerally more flexible, with fewer vehicle restrictions
If you cannot repayThe lender may repossess the vehicleThe lender may pursue debt recovery action

The exact features depend on the lender and loan agreement. Always check the terms before deciding.

Pros and Cons

Both loan types have advantages and disadvantages. Understanding them can help you decide which option is more appropriate for your circumstances.

Car Loan (Secured)

What’s good

  • Often offers lower interest rates than unsecured personal loans
  • May allow you to borrow larger amounts
  • Fixed-rate options can make repayments more predictable
  • Can be suitable for buying new or newer used vehicles

What’s not

  • The lender can repossess the vehicle if you default
  • Some lenders restrict the age, condition or type of vehicle
  • Private purchases may not be accepted by every lender
  • Extra repayments or early payout may attract restrictions or fees
  • Comprehensive insurance may be required

Personal Loan (Unsecured)

What’s good

  • You generally don’t need to use your vehicle as security
  • Can provide more flexibility when buying privately
  • May be suitable for older or lower-value vehicles
  • Funds may be used for additional purchase costs, depending on the loan terms
  • Some products offer flexible extra repayments

What’s not

  • Interest rates are often higher than secured car loans
  • Borrowing limits may be lower
  • Approval depends heavily on your income, expenses and credit history
  • Establishment and ongoing fees can increase the total cost
  • The lender can still take legal action to recover an unpaid debt

What Each Loan Really Costs

Interest rates can make a significant difference to the total cost of borrowing. Consider an illustrative example of borrowing $30,000 over five years.

$30,000 over 5 yearsSecured car loanUnsecured personal loan
Interest rate7.19% p.a.13.60% p.a.
Estimated monthly repayment$597$692
Estimated total repayments$35,820$41,520
Estimated interest paid$5,820$11,520

Illustrative estimates based on monthly principal-and-interest repayments, rounded to the nearest dollar. They exclude fees and other charges. Actual repayments will depend on the lender’s terms and the rate offered.

In this example, the unsecured personal loan costs approximately $95 more per month and around $5,700 more over five years.

The example shows why comparing interest rates and total repayment costs matters. However, a lower interest rate doesn’t automatically mean a better loan. Fees and repayment conditions can change the overall value.

Fees to Watch For

Interest isn’t the only cost to consider when taking out a car loan or personal loan. Different lenders may charge fees that increase the total amount you repay.

Common fees include:

  • Establishment or application fee: A one-off charge for setting up the loan.
  • Monthly account-keeping fee: An ongoing charge for maintaining the loan account.
  • Early repayment fee: Some fixed-rate loans may charge a fee or impose other conditions when you pay the loan off early.
  • Missed repayment fee: A charge that may apply when you don’t make a scheduled repayment on time.
  • Dealer or broker fees: Some vehicle finance arrangements include additional distribution or intermediary fees.

ASIC’s June 2026 review of Australia’s car finance sector, Report 832, found significant differences in establishment fees across more than 350,000 loans. In one case, a customer paid more than $9,000 in total establishment fees on a car loan of about $49,162.

This highlights why it’s important to check all fees before accepting a finance agreement.

What Happens If You Can’t Repay Your Loan?

It’s important to understand the consequences of missed repayments before taking on any debt.

With a secured car loan, the vehicle acts as collateral. If you fall behind on repayments and don’t resolve the default, the lender may be able to repossess and sell the car under the relevant agreement and legal requirements.

However, selling the vehicle doesn’t necessarily clear the entire debt. If the sale proceeds are less than the outstanding loan balance and associated costs, you may still owe the difference.

With an unsecured personal loan, the lender generally cannot repossess the car simply because you used the loan to buy it. However, that doesn’t mean the debt disappears if you stop paying.

The lender may contact you to recover the overdue amount, report relevant defaults in accordance with credit reporting rules, refer the debt to a collection agency or take legal action.

In either situation, missed repayments can affect your credit history and make future borrowing more difficult.

If you’re struggling to meet repayments, contact your lender as early as possible to discuss hardship assistance and available arrangements.

So, Which Loan Should You Pick?

For many people buying a new or nearly new vehicle, a secured car loan can be the more affordable option because it often comes with a lower interest rate.

An unsecured personal loan may be more suitable if you’re buying an older car, purchasing from a private seller or want greater flexibility over how you use the funds.

However, the interest rate alone shouldn’t determine your decision. Compare the comparison rate, fees, loan term, repayment flexibility and total amount repayable.

Taking the time to understand these differences can help you choose finance that suits your budget and avoid unnecessary borrowing costs.